SNI-23: SSH - Vulnerability in ssh-agent

Secure Networks Inc. (sni@SECURENETWORKS.COM)
Tue, 20 Jan 1998 15:42:15 -0700

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----

###### ## ## ######
## ### ## ##
###### ## # ## ##
## ## ### ##
###### . ## ## . ######.

Secure Networks Inc.

Security Advisory
January 20, 1998

Vulnerability in ssh-agent

This advisory details a vulnerabily in the SSH cryptographic login
program. The vulnerability enables users to use RSA credentials
belonging to other users who use the ssh-agent program. This
vulnerability may allow an attacker on the same local host to login
to a remote server as the user utilizing SSH.

Problem Description:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

In order to avoid forcing users of RSA based authentication to go
through the trouble of retyping their pass phrase every time they wish
to use ssh, slogin, or scp, the SSH package includes a program called
ssh-agent, which manages RSA keys for the SSH program. The ssh-agent
program creates a mode 700 directory in /tmp, and then creates an
AF_UNIX socket in that directory. Later, the user runs the ssh-add
program, which adds his private key to the set of keys managed by the
ssh-agent program. When the user wishes to access a service which
permits him to log in using only his RSA key, the SSH client connects
to the AF_UNIX socket, and asks the ssh-agent program for the key.

Unfortunately, when connecting to the AF_UNIX socket, the SSH client is
running as super-user, and performs insufficient permissions checking.
This makes it possible for users to trick their SSH clients into using
credentials belonging to other users. The end result is that any user
who utilizes RSA authentication AND uses ssh-agent, is vulnerable.
Attackers can utilize this vulnerability to access remote accounts
belonging to the ssh-agent user.

Technical Details
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

When communicating with the ssh-agent program, the SSH program issues a
connect() system call as super-user to access the AF_UNIX socket. By
utilizing symbolic links, an attacker can cause the SSH program to
connect to an alternate user's AF_UNIX socket, and read their RSA
credentials. After the credentials have been read, SSH will use these
credentials to logon to the remote system as the victim.

Vulnerable Systems:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

This vulnerability effects the Unix versions of SSH ONLY.

SSH for unix versions 1.2.17 through 1.2.21 are vulnerable if installed
with default permissions. Versions of SSH prior to 1.2.17 are subject to
a similar (but different) attack.

F-Secure SSH for Unix systems prior to release 1.3.3 ARE vulnerable.

You can determine the version of SSH you are running by issuing the case
sensitive command:

% ssh -V

Version 1.1 of the windows-based SSH client sold by Data Fellows Inc.
under the F-Secure brand name is NOT vulnerable to this attack.

Versions 1.0 and 1.0a of Mac SSH are NOT vulnerable to this attack.

Fix Resolution:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Non-commercial users:

If using the free non-commercial SSH distribution for Unix, administrators
are urged to upgrade to SSH 1.2.22 or later. Updated versions of the free
unix SSH can be found at ftp://ftp.cs.hut.fi/pub/ssh

Commercial users:

F-Secure SSH version 1.3.3 fixes this security problem. If you are using
the commercial Data Fellows SSH package and you have a support contract,
you can obtain SSH version 1.3.3 from your local retailer.

Users without a support contract can obtain a diff file which fixes
this problem. This file can be obtained from:

http://www.DataFellows.com/f-secure/support/ssh/bug/su132patch.html

Workaround:

As a temporary workaround, administrators may remove the setuid bit from
the SSH binary. This will prevent the attack from working, but will
disable a form of authentication documented as rhosts-RSA. For example,
if your SSH binary is in the /usr/local/bin directory, the following
command will remove the setuid bit from the SSH binary:

# chmod u-s /usr/local/bin/ssh

Additional Information
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

SSH is a cryptographic rsh, rlogin, and rcp replacement. SSH was
written by Tatu Ylonen <ylo@cs.hut.fi>. For more information about the
noncommercial unix version of SSH, please see http://www.cs.hut.fi/ssh

Commercial versions of ssh are marketed by Data Fellows Inc. For
information about the F-secure ssh derivatives sold by Data Fellows Inc,
please see http://www.DataFellows.com/f-secure

This vulnerability was discovered by David Sacerdote <davids@secnet.com>.

For more information regarding this advisory, contact Secure Networks
Inc. as <sni@secnet.com>. A PGP public key is provided below if
privacy is required.

Type Bits/KeyID Date User ID
pub 1024/9E55000D 1997/01/13 Secure Networks Inc. <sni@secnet.com>
Secure Networks <security@secnet.com>

- -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: 2.6.3ia
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=DchE
- -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

Copyright Notice
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The contents of this advisory are Copyright (C) 1997 Secure Networks
Inc, and may be distributed freely provided that no fee is charged for
distribution, and that proper credit is given.

You can find Secure Networks papers at ftp://ftp.secnet.com/pub/papers
and advisories at ftp://ftp.secnet.com/advisories

You can browse our web site at http://www.secnet.com

You can subscribe to our security advisory mailing list by sending mail
to majordomo@secnet.com with the line "subscribe sni-advisories"

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: 2.6.3ia
Charset: noconv

iQCVAwUBNMUgALgIhFKeVQANAQH25AP+IsM09N1MXI6z8gA6nWNwmrvT2Bf+m/Fq
k+CKeXdpTO+7YDKXXDtLquOEOYnZpKl+UZr0xGcVX1v01uddGHowADQlApEeajPJ
rftuKMK7SL2WJ3Iv2olhHotqEuFgmKw1Xu6KLxmANssGbuQvRgdI+Zr7Nt4irpcQ
BredVG8qNcY=
=f6CF
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----